Regulation

U.S. Justice Department Backs Patent Trolls in Push to Weaken Injunction Safeguards

The government is intervening in patent disputes to make it easier for non-practicing entities to obtain injunctions that could shut down entire product lines, undermining two decades of legal protections.

6 min read
The Justice Department Wants To Give Patent Trolls More Power

The landscape of software patent litigation has long been dominated by entities with no manufacturing operations. These organizations acquire intellectual property portfolios specifically to extract settlements through legal action and threats of litigation. The fundamental problem: a single patented component should not grant an owner the ability to halt production of an entire device.

Yet this is precisely the outcome that patent assertion entities are pursuing—and the current administration is facilitating their efforts. Through filings in two recent cases, Radian Memory Systems v. Samsung and Collision Communications v. Samsung, the Justice Department and U.S. Patent and Trademark Office have urged courts to expand the circumstances under which patent holders can obtain injunctions. These court orders compel companies to cease product sales or eliminate features rather than simply remit financial compensation.

The leverage created by an injunction threat can force companies to settle for amounts far exceeding a patent's genuine value. In 2006, NTP Inc., which produced no commercial products, pressured BlackBerry maker Research in Motion Ltd. into a $612 million settlement as an injunction loomed.

Protection Against Patent Trolls

Two decades ago, the Supreme Court moved to curtail this dynamic. In eBay v. MercExchange, decided in May 2006, the justices rejected the routine granting of permanent injunctions following patent infringement findings. The ruling established that patent holders must clear the same demanding threshold as other plaintiffs: demonstrating "irreparable harm," showing that monetary remedies would prove inadequate, establishing that the "balance of hardships" supports their position, and critically, proving that an injunction would not damage the "public interest."

The Electronic Frontier Foundation hailed eBay v. MercExchange as a landmark victory for internet users. The organization had warned years earlier that software patents posed a threat not merely to smaller enterprises but to online free expression itself. In its court filing, EFF noted:

The United States Patent and Trademark Office has issued patents on methods fordownloading video programs, publishing web pages, sending email messages, making internet telephone calls, and even online fundraising methods. Injunctions against uses of these technologies—and many similar technologies—will inevitably affect, and may even chill, free expression on the internet.

Electronic Frontier Foundation

The eBay framework rests on sound reasoning: patent monopolies derive their justification from advancing innovation and scientific progress. Patent enforcement should not come at the expense of subsequent innovators, expression rights, or technology accessibility.

Now, twenty years later, the government is pushing courts to reinterpret these protections in ways that would strengthen patent holders' negotiating position. Government intervention in private patent disputes remains uncommon, yet this administration has repeatedly inserted itself—consistently favoring patent owners over public interests.

Patent Licensing Disputes Shouldn't Threaten Entire Product Lines

In June 2025, the Justice Department and Patent Office submitted a "statement of interest" in Radian Memory Systems v. Samsung, a dispute centered on patents covering solid-state drives—storage technology ubiquitous in modern computing. Radian, a patent assertion entity connected to Fortress Investment Group, sought a preliminary injunction to halt Samsung product sales before any determination of actual patent infringement.

The government's filing contended that a patent owner whose entire business model depends on patent licensing could suffer irreparable harm, since calculating appropriate compensation presents difficulties. According to the DOJ brief: "In cases of unique assets, courts have commonly found irreparable harm when damages are difficult to calculate."

However, courts routinely resolve disputes over royalty rates, patent contribution valuations, and comparable licensing arrangements. The mere existence of such disagreements does not establish that monetary compensation would prove insufficient. Should courts embrace the DOJ's reasoning, ordinary patent litigation complexities could become grounds for finding irreparable harm, lowering the bar for injunctions that endanger entire product portfolios. Patent-licensing-only businesses would gain tremendous advantage—they could routinely pursue injunctions, as eBay's most critical protections eroded.

The government further argued that "the prospect of an injunction can facilitate negotiation among the parties." This observation identifies the core problem. A company facing shutdown threats will likely pay substantial sums to patent litigation entities to preserve product continuity and customer relationships. Such payments reflect the coercive value of the threat rather than the patent's actual worth. Radian ultimately abandoned its preliminary injunction request, though the government's arguments regarding injunction availability remain troubling.

A Second Attempt To Weaken eBay

Strikingly, the government resurrected this argument in February 2025 in Collision Communications v. Samsung, a case that had already proceeded to trial. Collision, a patent-licensing entity that obtained its patents from a defense contractor, won a $445.5 million jury verdict for infringing four patents and subsequently sought an injunction.

Despite the jury awarding Collision $445.5 million in damages, the government intervened again, arguing that non-manufacturing patent owners should not be denied injunctions simply because they rely on licensing revenue. The government also repeated its claim that calculating damages difficulties can justify injunctions.

Though U.S. District Court Judge Rodney Gilstrap found that Collision had suffered irreparable harm and that monetary damages would be inadequate, he rejected Collision's position that ongoing infringement automatically establishes irreparable harm. He ultimately denied the injunction because Collision failed to satisfy two additional eBay requirements: demonstrating that hardship balance favored an injunction and that an injunction would not harm public interests.

Collision has now appealed to the Federal Circuit, the nation's premier patent tribunal. The Public Interest Patent Law Institute (PIPLI) submitted a brief explaining the stakes: when a patent owner manufactures nothing, an injunction can deprive the public of essential technology entirely. Given that these patents concern mobile phone connections to cellular networks, "the effect on the public goes far beyond what these patents claim as improvements," PIPLI noted.

The implications extend beyond these two companies. The eBay test requires courts to weigh who benefits and who suffers from a permanent injunction, including the broader public. A patent owner's desire for enhanced negotiating leverage should not supersede the interests of millions relying on their mobile devices. Yet the government's arguments could precisely enable patent owners to obtain such leverage at public expense.

The Government Should Protect the Public, Not Patent Owners

Patent holders already possess mechanisms to recover damages and royalties when infringement occurs. They should not receive an expedited path to shutting down technology products merely because damages calculations require effort.

The Justice Department must defend the eBay protections. Instead, this administration is assisting patent owners in circumventing them. Courts should decline these arguments. Strengthening patent threats' value does not serve the public interest.

Source: Electronic Frontier Foundation · Reporting supplemented by The Silicon Ledger staff.